Pages

Sunday, December 2, 2012

Judges Exegetical Paper Part 1

The first few pages of my paper on Judges 11:29-40.

As the pages of Biblical history turned from the great conquests of Joshua, a period of confusion and chaos fill the void of leadership. This period forms the content of the book of Judges. Thus the book of Judges records a historical record of sorts of the people of Israel during this stage in their development as a nation and a culture.

However, it is not so simple to evaluate the setting of Judges by studying the clear historical landmarks of the contents of the book directly. Instead, the reader must recognize that two cultural settings are in view and impact the tone and meaning of the book as a whole. The first and most obvious culture under view is that of the time period of the events described in the book directly.

Following the death of Moses, Joshua took the leadership reigns for the nation of Israel and led the people into the land that was promised. The long travel was complete but the battle for the land was just beginning. The book of Joshua records a series of battles and settlements as the people made the land their own.

Yet as battles were won and the land is apportioned to tribes, the people spread out and placed roots in the conquered cities and towns. Joshua served for many years as a central and strong leader with a network of helpers. Following the death of Joshua, no clear leader is established for the people. Joshua himself charges the people en masse to follow and serve God.

While Joshua makes clear in his closing charge that the people will not be prone to obey the law he describes, he does nothing to prepare them for the troubles or difficulties which lie ahead. Indeed, the closing words of the book of Joshua set the ominous tone for the setting of Judges. “So Joshua sent the people away, every man to his inheritance.”

This “every man” motif not only sets the appropriate stage of Judges but serves as a grammatical bookmark throughout the book. With no clear leader, the nation become subject to the waves of power and national struggle. That lack of leadership was not confined only the nation itself but was mirrored by the region as a whole. Daniel Block mentions the lack of information regarding this time period found in the pages of Scripture. In addition as well, he adds that “exrabiblical sources for the period of the judges are scarce.” Since history in the ancient world was normally driven by singular leaders and kings, such a lack of documentation suggest a period both of frequent war and destruction but the marked absence of either a dominating nation or king.

This absence of leadership or power affected the region with numerous national strife events and oppression. The numerous socio-political groups or nations mentioned in the book of Judges reflect constant fighting and war. In addition, the nation of Israel found such strife internally as well including civil war of sorts. Herbert Wolf lists these conflicts in his description. “Ephraim was ravaged by Manasseh (ch. 12), and Benjamin was almost annihilated by the other tribes (chs. 20-21).”

In terms of religious views of the times, Judges itself reflects a people who were misled. The repeated habit of turning to God displays the truth that the people in general had a technical knowledge of the worship of the God. Block agrees by stating “although little is known about the practice of official national religion at this time, these data demonstrate that throughout the period of settlement the Israelite tribes retained a consciousness of their status as the people of Yahweh.”

What the people knew to be true at the time was however not often relevant. Their practice, rather than knowledge, was that of pursuing what is termed in Judges as “Baals and the Asherahs.” Baal specifically was the most well known god of the time and his connection to winter rain became symbolic of fertility. He is often found in connection with two other goddesses. Asherah who was considered to be the mother of Baal was one while Ashtoreth was the god of war and sex. Any extensive study into the premonarchial period of Israelite history should involve an extensive study of these gods and what they represent and how their worship impacted the cultures of the world.

In short however, the worship of these idols demonstrate a clear cultural emphasis. Worship of Baal and Asherah/Ashtoreth were a vital aspect of agricultural people groups at that time period of history. The desire for fertile crops, the source of wealth and prosperity, became the main religious focus. As the nation of Israel moved from a nomadic livestock driven people to a stable agricultural people, the absorption of the religious connections to that lifestyle became natural. It is necessary to see the religious struggles of Israel not merely as a worship failure, but a lifestyle and cultural development in conflict with God’s plan. Thus the leadership vacuum, civil war and religious apostasy set the key cultural stages upon which the drama of Judges would be played.

In addition as well, the second culture to be evaluated is of course that of the time period during which the book was written. This culture is less important in understanding the stories but far more important to understand the intended meaning and inclusion of the stories. It is only from this view of the writing world that one can grasp the functional importance and appreciation for the message of the book of Judges.

The general consensus regarding the writing of the book of Judges is during the timeframe of Israel when the nation was unified under one king. The impetus for this dating centers on both the tone of the book and the frequent references to the time being without a king. Such a comment would suggest that the original reader would understand the contrast. More specific dating is difficult although some commentators suggest an early Davidic reign due to the mention of Jerusalem belonging to the Jebusites in 1:21.

The significance of this date would be greatly meaningful to the specific occasion of this book. Prior to the conquest of Jerusalem, David was not fully accepted as king over all of Israel. After the death of Saul, David was made king of Judah publically. However, 2 Samuel 3 records an ongoing war between the family of Saul and David. David ruled at this time from the city of Hebron. It is not until after the conquest of Jerusalem that one can see a clear kingdom for David emerging. “At Hebron he reigned over Judah seven years and six months, and at Jerusalem he reigned over all Israel and Judah thirty-three years.” Thus the key cultural aspect of the timeframe of the writing of Judges is the gradual movement toward a secure king and nation. 

While God has recognized David as king, the people of Israel as a whole have completely accepted neither that kingship nor God’s involvement in the affairs of Israel. With this in mind, one can clearly see the overarching emphasis of the book of Judges. It becomes of sorts a political campaign for the people to support David and pursue God. The anonymous author makes clear that the alternative to a God fearing leader is chaos and violence. Instead, by accepting and following God and his appointed servant, the people of Israel can expect blessing and security. It is upon these cultural settings that one must approach and understand the book of Judges.

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

General Hermeneutical Thoughts

During this semester in school, I have been studying the topic of hermeneutics. A fancy word that basically means we are learning how to study the Bible well. It may seem at first glance to be a relatively non essential class. Some would even argue that the Holy Spirit helps you to understand when you read so why learn how to understand. But there was a thought in one of my textbooks that made an excellent point. The general idea was a challenge to truly study the Bible. If one only grabs from Scripture the lessons of a casual reading, there are numerous unintended consequences. The first is that you tend to read only those things that seem to make sense to you. Thus without more focused study, many passages that don't make sense at first glance will be neglected. Secondly then you will eventually begin to only see what you have already learned. If there is never education or study in certain areas of knowledge, you will only bring to the text what you already knew. Over time, this will render the Word quite shallow and repetitive. This is not the fault of the Bible but the failure of the reader to truly grasp what the Bible is. The third consequence is that in the interest of preserving interest, you are more likely to find "new" and "exciting" meanings to the text which are incorrect. The natural mind cannot understand the things of God and the natural (or non spiritually focused) mind will look for meanings based upon human comprehension.  I guess that what I realized upon reading these warnings was why many people struggle with or don't find purpose in daily reading of the Bible. Without real study, many things begin to look the same and the concept of lighthearted reading doesn't accomplish very much. The meaning of Scripture is forever bound first in what the Bible meant to the original reader. To get to the point of truly understanding Scripture, you must cross the cultural, philosophical and other barriers to place yourself in the place of the original reader. Crossing those barriers takes work and study and time. But it is that focus which opens the door to truly grasping and loving the Word of God. If you are interested in how to do this, I have a few good books which help you learn the steps toward understanding all of Scripture better.

Sunday, October 14, 2012

Paper Conclusion

I just finished my lengthy paper on the Fundamentalist-Modernist Controversy. Below is the final section from the paper. If  you want to read the whole 19 pages, let me know and I will email you a copy.


While Fundamentalism as a movement became separate and discounted at the time, the course of history has shown several growing lessons from the changes of the controversy. Fundamentalism became separate from culture and thus culture showed through its art a decline in order and meaning. Likewise, the modernist movement, with no real answer regarding truth or hermeneutic, lost impact and passion in the churches. This is reflected as previously mentioned in schools such as Princeton Seminary which lost viability as the standard bearer of truth. To this day, there is a nondescript and lacking theological statement on the website of the seminary.
With the emphasis on the social pragmatism of faith, modernism was forced, and has demonstrated over the years, an unbridled connection with the whims of the standards of the world. There is a growing disconnect between these churches and culture since they no longer offer a set of beliefs contrary to the general morality of culture.
On the contrary, the fundamentalist movement continues to stand opposed to culture and both preach and teach the need for individuals to change. The Southern Baptist Convention fought to turn away from a growth toward modernism and liberalism and now stands united with the various denominations which represent the legacy of fundamentalism. It is this legacy now which stands situated to represent and address the growing problem in modern America.
The reality at the inception of the fundamentalist-modernist controversy was a world infatuated with science and the progressive hope of mankind. That which could be achieved seemed vast and a religion emphatic on the absolute inerrancy of an archaic book seemed both preposterous and dangerous. Thus, an adaptive religion took hold which balanced the morality and community of church with the advances and hope of scientific progress.
However, as the century came to a close and the twenty-first century began, a new reality has emerged more clearly. Science and technology have indeed increased and brought the world in increasing interaction with one another. The remnants of modernism, with a potentially errant Scripture, can offer only cooperation with the religions of the world and not hope. Yet religion in general is now viewed as either worthless or harmful. The actions of September 11, 2001 helped cement that extreme devotion to a religious ideal was potentially even destructive.
These factors present the individual with a world both of confusion and devoid of meaning. Modernism promoted science but science without a God only promoted hopelessness. Technology can enhance life but it cannot extend it. Each individual’s place in the world is becoming more and more meaningless. Likewise an integrated individuality enhances the concept that each person’s belief system is personal and not communicative. With no overarching meaning or relationship, mankind is alone in all the noise and confusion of the world.
Against such a backdrop, the modernist churches no longer have real answers. They can offer only community and belonging of a temporal nature. It is now clear that fundamentalism and the basis of belief upon which it was founded continues to offer the best answer for a world in need. It is in short here delineated the core aspects of fundamentalism and how they offer a response to the world today.
Fundamentalism claimed from the beginning that the Bible is the inerrant Word of a sovereign God. Such a God is thus not constrained to the limits of time or the machinations of man. As such, the Bible becomes a source of timeless revelation when interpreted in light of it cultural writing. Its story of a personal God and the incarnation and resurrection paint a picture far different not only than any other religion (including modernism) but of significant meaning to the world.
This reality stand contra juxtaposed to both modern society and that which could be called post-modern. As the world has moved away from modernity to a more pessimistic reality, the unchanging nature of an inerrant Scripture poses a set of answers for a new generation of questions. The Bible issues both an understanding of a greater purpose for man as well as hope for a future after life. The Bible explains the meaning of singular truth and the reason that such truth is not oppressive.
These truths are found only from the fundamental basis of interpreting and understanding Scripture. It is without question then that as modernist churches die without answers, fundamentalism and the churches which cling to its core principles carry an inherent hope built upon the Bible. It remains thus for the fundamentalist movement to recognize the potential and answer the call for this generation. It is no longer a question of fighting against other churches. Fundamentalism must recognize its place and humbly offer a hurting world the timeless truths of the faithful gospel.

Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Interesting Book?

Below is a quote from a sports article ("TMQ" on espn.com). The quote references a book which sounds quite interesting from everything I have read. I have not yet however read the book so I am not recommending it. It does seem that the book will present some interesting points for discussion.

"Love him or hate him, on this subject you've got to read Charles Murray's new book "Coming Apart." His big point is that well-off liberals should "preach what they practice" -- that denizens of the high-income zip codes in blue states themselves have two-parent households with conventional marriages, strict work ethics and high educational achievement, yet contend no one should be judgmental about out-of-wedlock birth, bad public schools or welfare. Murray presents overwhelming evidence that although it's assumed anything goes in the sinful liberal cities while tradition rules in the Bible Belt, in the last generation it's been the other way around -- red states are plagued by divorce and teen pregnancy, blue states have conventional family values.
Coming from a radioactive conservative, this analysis is unsettling. Liberals, Murray charges, are harming the underclass by asserting that all lifestyles are equally valid -- when they know from their own experience that conventional behavior leads to the best economic and educational outcomes."

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Saving Money on Proofreading

I recently was afforded the opportunity to donate money to Madison County. Even though I have decided not to contest the opportunity, I figured that the generic ticket handed to me is fair game for proofreading. Considering they made a point of asking me to "read carefully," I will assume that I can critique their poor proofreading skills. Both grammar and typing seem to be an issue.